Should I trade Marion Barber for David Garrard?

My RBs as of now: Gore, Turner, Marion Barber, and Pierre Thomas


My QBs: Jay Cutler, Jake Delhomme





League starts: 2 RBs, 1 QB, 1 QB/RB/WR super flex w/6 pt passing touchdownsShould I trade Marion Barber for David Garrard?
You can do much better than Garrard for Marion Barber. You've got some decent RBs , which means someone would want him, but aim a bit higher! Garrard is completely inconsistent and it's not even a matchup thing - there's just no telling what he'll do.Should I trade Marion Barber for David Garrard?
No way you give-up the Barbarian for a backup QB like Garrard. Delhomme has a nice matchup v. Bucs...did you see what McNabb did this past Sunday. IF you trade a starting RB, you should get back a #1 QB...not a bye week fill-in like Garrard. At least a top 10 guy. Garrard is at best, 15-20.
U have good rbs n jay cutler is real good n should always be ur number 1 but David garrard is suspect I wouldn't trade someone like Marion for David unless one of ur other qbs gets injured...as another qb Kyle Orton should b out there as a free agent or mayb even Tampas new QB consider some1 off the free agent list
If you think you need a QB then yes. Your stocked on RBs once Gore and Thomas get fully healed. Good luck.
Only if your a dumbass...