Kolby Smith v Detroit or Marion Barber v Carolina?

I'm leaning toward Barber, but he's been so inconsistent... Your help is truly appreciated!Kolby Smith v Detroit or Marion Barber v Carolina?
and Smith is consistent? He had one great game against Oakland (everybody does against them). Other than that he's been a generally adequate back on a weak offense that's near te bottom of the NFL in rushing. I would go with Barber.Kolby Smith v Detroit or Marion Barber v Carolina?
kolby smith their playing the 21st rush def. also barber might be splitting carries.
I'd go with Barber. Since Romo's hand is injured they'll put more emphasis on the running attack.
Hmm the nobody or the Pro Bowler........inconsistent? The only inconsistency in Marion Barbers game is how many touches he gets, if the coaches would implement him more in the offense he is a threat for 100 yards every single game, and his hands out of the backfield are ridiculously awesome. The last 2 seasons only 1 guy has had more TD's (LT) and Barber was recognized with a Pro Bowl appearance b/c of his abusiveness and physical prowess out of the backfield. Only 2 players in the NFL who have had the same amt or more carries than him have a better YPC (4.9 for Marion Barber) and he has 9 rushing TD's this season despite less than 180 carries. Barber is the obvious choice.
id go with barber